Halloween is all about fun and treats, but let’s be real—not every treat has to be candy. Whether you're looking to avoid sugar overload, accommodate allergies, or just want to mix things up a bit, non-candy Halloween treats are a fantastic option. Even though my kids don’t have dietary restrictions (it’s my husband who needs to be gluten-free), I’ve found that offering different options is always a hit.
Over the years, I’ve noticed that kids get just as excited—if not more—about the fun, non-candy goodies they find in their treat bags. Plus, as a mom, I love knowing I’m handing out something that everyone can enjoy, whether they have allergies, dietary needs, or just a mountain of candy already at home.
In this guide, I’m sharing my top picks for non-candy Halloween treats that will bring smiles to all the little ghosts and goblins at your door. Whether you're focused on health, safety, or just keeping things interesting, these ideas will help you create a Halloween that’s memorable and stress-free.
Jump to:
The gluten-free guide below is based on personal experience and research. Always be sure to discuss any medical changes with your doctor for your personal medical needs. Additionally, this post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. My full disclosure isn’t that interesting, but you can find it here.
Take this quick quiz and uncover the secrets to making your gluten-free lifestyle not just manageable, but truly enjoyable with custom recipes and tips!
🎃 20 Non-Candy Halloween Treats
Now that we’ve talked about why non-candy treats are a great option, let’s dive into the fun part—choosing what to hand out! Whether you’re participating in the Teal Pumpkin Project or just want to offer something unique, these 20 non-candy Halloween treats are sure to be a hit.
From glow-in-the-dark goodies to fun toys, these ideas are perfect for kids of all ages and are a great way to make your Halloween a little more inclusive and memorable. So, let’s get to it—here are my top picks for non-candy Halloween treats!
-
$7.99Buy NowThese glitter sticky hands are a total win for Halloween goodie bags! As a mom, I think they’re a super fun, non-candy treat that kids absolutely love. They come in bright colors and are individually wrapped, making them perfect for trick-or-treating. Plus, they’re a great value—you get 72 of them!
They stick well, and the glitter adds a nice touch. Perfect for keeping little hands busy!
01/19/2025 05:22 am GMT -
$17.95Buy Now
These lifelike insect toys are a fantastic addition to Halloween goodie bags! I feel these are a fun and educational treat that kids will totally enjoy. The variety is awesome—100 different insects, reptiles, and more! They’re not just bugs but also frogs, snakes, and even bats, which adds to the excitement. The detail and colors are impressive, and the softer plastic makes them safe and durable.
I think kids love the realistic look, and they’re perfect for trick-or-treating, especially for little ones who love nature and science. An absolute hit for Halloween!
08/15/2024 03:12 pm GMT -
$7.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed pencils are a fun and practical alternative to candy for trick-or-treaters! As a mom, I love that they bring a bit of Halloween spirit to something kids can actually use (i.e. it's not extra clutter). The variety of designs—like pumpkins, witches, and mummies—makes them super festive and exciting for kids to collect.
These make perfect goodies for school parties or trick-or-treat bags, offering a little treat that kids can enjoy long after Halloween is over.
01/19/2025 05:23 am GMT -
$8.13Buy Now
These Halloween stickers are a fun, affordable, and non-candy alternative for trick-or-treaters! With 500 stickers featuring various spooky designs, you’ll have more than enough to go around. I love that they’re even cheaper than buying candy.
Plus, stickers are always a hit—kids can stick them on their notebooks, crafts, or wherever their imagination takes them. A simple, mess-free option that kids will love!
01/19/2025 05:28 am GMT -
$12.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed erasers are a delightful treat for trick-or-treaters and a great alternative to candy! I was pleasantly surprised by their size—bigger and sturdier than I expected, which makes them even more fun for kids. The designs, featuring classic Halloween characters like vampires and pumpkins, are super cute and perfect for adding a festive touch. Plus, they actually do a decent job erasing pencil marks.
I think they’re a fantastic, non-candy option for goodie bags, and they’re a great value for the price!
01/19/2025 05:33 am GMT -
$6.95Buy Now
These classic plastic spider rings are a Halloween staple and seriously a must-have for any spooky celebration! With 144 pieces in the pack, you’ll have more than enough to deck out your trick-or-treat bags or use as party decorations.
I love how they’re just the right size to be fun but not too scary for the little ones. One thing to note, though—they come as solid rings, so they may not fit bigger kids without being snipped. A great, affordable choice for adding that creepy-crawly vibe to your Halloween festivities.
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
01/19/2025 05:33 am GMT -
$29.99Buy Now
These glow-in-the-dark Halloween bounce balls are an absolute hit for trick-or-treat bags! With 72 in the pack and six different spooky designs, they’re perfect for adding some playful fun to your Halloween festivities. Kids go wild for bouncy balls, and the glow-in-the-dark feature just takes it to the next level.
I thought these balls were a major success—some glowed better than others, but overall, they were a big hit. Plus, you get great value for the price, making them a fantastic, non-candy treat for Halloween!
01/19/2025 05:34 am GMT -
$21.99Buy Now
These pre-inked stampers are an absolute treasure for Halloween goodie bags or any party favor! With 100 stamps in 50 unique designs—ranging from dinosaurs to Halloween themes—there’s something for everyone. The self-inking feature makes them almost mess-free and perfect for little hands. My kids love stampers; stampers are some of their favorite craft supplies and use them on everything from cards to scrapbooks.
The vibrant colors and variety make them a standout option, and they last a long time, too. Plus, they’re super affordable, so you get a ton of fun without breaking the bank. A must-have for Halloween or any festive occasion!
01/19/2025 05:34 am GMT -
$22.99Buy Now
These ultra-bright glow sticks are a total game-changer for Halloween! They’re perfect for keeping kids visible while trick-or-treating, and the fun factor is off the charts. With vibrant colors like yellow, green, pink, and more, kids will love making bracelets, necklaces, and even crowns. The glow lasts for hours, so the fun doesn’t fade too soon.
While they might not be the sturdiest, that actually makes them easier for little hands to bend into fun shapes. All in all, a fantastic, affordable treat that kids adore!
01/19/2025 05:34 am GMT -
$9.99Buy Now
These Halloween silicone bracelets are a super fun alternative to candy for trick-or-treaters! With 42 bracelets in seven different designs, they’re perfect for adding a festive touch to Halloween celebrations. I love that they’re made of durable silicone, so they stretch to fit both kids and adults comfortably. The variety of designs—like bats, pumpkins, and “Trick or Treat” messages—really capture the Halloween spirit.
If you’re looking to hand out something a little different this year, these bracelets are a fantastic, crowd-pleasing choice!
01/19/2025 05:34 am GMT -
$8.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed mini bubble wands are an absolute treat for any spooky celebration! With 32 adorable designs like bats, pumpkins, and ghosts, they’re perfect for adding a playful touch to Halloween festivities. It's amazing how many kids will choose these bubbles over candy—they are always a huge hit! The bubbles themselves are vibrant and plentiful, and the wands are the perfect size for little hands. Plus, they’re prefilled with a non-toxic solution, so they’re safe for everyone.
Whether you're looking for a non-candy alternative or just something fun to hand out, these bubbles are a fantastic choice!
01/19/2025 05:43 am GMT -
$6.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed mini slinkies are a super fun addition to any Halloween goodie bag! With 24 in the pack, each featuring spooky designs like skulls and black cats in festive colors, they’re bound to be a crowd-pleaser. Kids will love stretching and watching them bounce back—slinkies never go out of style! They’re not just fun; they also help develop fine motor skills, making them a great choice for classroom rewards or party favors.
If you’re looking for a playful, budget-friendly alternative to candy, these slinkies are a fantastic choice!
01/19/2025 05:38 am GMT -
Buy Now
These mini Halloween pop fidget toys are a total win for trick-or-treat bags! With 32 keychain-sized fidgets in fun shapes, they’re perfect for kids to attach to a backpack and play with anytime. The popping sound is oddly satisfying and a great stress reliever, making them a hit with kids and even older siblings. I love that they’re also cute enough to use as Halloween decorations. Just a heads-up: you’ll need to attach the keychains yourself, but they’re still fantastic without them.
These are always a top pick among Halloween goodies—definitely a must-have!
-
$4.99Buy Now
These glow-in-the-dark Halloween tattoos are an absolute hit for trick-or-treaters and party favors! With 204 individually wrapped sheets, you’ll have plenty to hand out, and kids will love the fun, spooky glow in the dark designs. They’re super easy to apply and last longer than most temporary tattoos I’ve seen.
While some might not glow as brightly as others, they’re still a huge crowd-pleaser and perfect for standing out at any Halloween event.
01/19/2025 05:39 am GMT -
$14.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed reusable straws are a fantastic non-candy option for trick-or-treaters or party favors! With 24 straws featuring fun designs like pumpkins and ghosts, they’re sure to be a hit with kids. The straws are made from sturdy, food-grade plastic, so they can be used again and again—just give them a handwash after each use. A unique and practical treat that’s sure to be a crowd-pleaser!
01/19/2025 05:39 am GMT -
$8.99Buy Now
These Halloween slap bracelets are an absolute blast for trick-or-treaters or party favors! With 48 bracelets featuring 16 different spooky designs, they’re sure to be a hit with kids and preteens alike. My kids can't get enough of them—they love slap bracelets. The quality is impressive; they’re durable and the prints are vibrant and long-lasting.
Perfect as a fun alternative to candy, these bracelets make great Halloween goodies, party favors, or classroom treats. They’re a nostalgic favorite that never goes out of style!
01/19/2025 05:39 am GMT -
$23.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed rubber duckies are a delightful treat for any Halloween celebration! With 24 unique designs (no repeats!), they’re perfect for adding a spooky twist to bath time or handing out as fun, non-candy goodies. I love how each duck is different, making them a hit with kids who enjoy collecting or playing with them.
The quality is great, and they’re made from non-toxic rubber, so they’re safe for little ones to enjoy in the bath, pool, or even at the beach. Plus, they’re easy to clean, which is always a bonus. A super cute and fun choice for Halloween treats or party favors!
01/19/2025 05:39 am GMT -
$9.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed bookmark rulers are a fantastic candy-free option for trick-or-treaters or party favors! With 144 bookmarks featuring six fun designs, they’re both cute and practical. I love that they double as rulers, making them a fun and useful gift for kids. The bookmarks are made of durable, lightweight vinyl, so they’ll last for multiple seasons. Although they’re a bit translucent, the vibrant colors and charming characters more than make up for it.
Perfect for adding to Halloween gift packs or handing out on their own—kids will definitely appreciate this unique and thoughtful treat!
08/15/2024 05:57 pm GMT -
$15.99Buy Now
These LED finger projection lights are a super cool and unique Halloween treat that kids will absolutely love! These flashlights project fun Halloween-themed patterns when you press the button. Kids will be thrilled to get these, especially when they see the shadows the lights create—instant excitement! While a few images might be a bit blurry, most are sharp and bright, making them a standout in any Halloween goodie bag.
They're easy to use and a fantastic non-candy option that’s sure to be a hit at parties or during trick-or-treating!
01/19/2025 05:48 am GMT -
$9.99Buy Now
These Halloween-themed squishy toys are a huge hit for both kids and adults! My kids love incorporating squishies into their games, and they’re perfect for stress relief with their soft, squeezable texture. While they do pick up lint easily, they're washable and still a popular choice for non-food treats. The individual wrapping is a nice touch, making them easy to hand out.
Overall, they’re a fun and playful option that kids will enjoy!
01/19/2025 05:43 am GMT
I hope these non-candy Halloween treats have inspired you to think outside the (candy) box this year!
Whether you're trying to accommodate dietary restrictions or just want to switch things up, these ideas are sure to make your Halloween a little more special.
What's they key to loving your gluten free life? Get your personalized plan with the guide you need to thrive!
But I’d love to hear from you—do you have any favorite non-candy Halloween treats or Teal Pumpkin Project ideas? Share your suggestions or ask any questions in the comments below.
Let’s keep the conversation going and make this Halloween the best one yet!
Hailey
This is a good idea! Especially if you don’t want to load children on sugar! Thanks for the tips!
thehelpfulgf
Yes! They already get enough candy that day, don't they?
Candice
Some great ideas. And they last longer too. The pumpkin stress balls are really cute.
thehelpfulgf
I thought they were cute too!
Aimey
I love these ideas. We don't eat a lot of candy in our house so these ideas are so helpful . Thanks for sharing!
Sandy
Great ideas! We always end up with a ton of leftover Halloween candy that I don't want to feed to my kid. These would certainly be healthy alternatives for leftovers after the holiday.
Emma
Great ideas! I know my siblings would much prefer fun things over candy. The toys last longer and can be used over and over again!
DionaLeigh
A big non-candy thank you! The thought of a huge haul of sugar is giving me a headache as we speak!!
thehelpfulgf
Yes! Sometimes you just need to avoid the sugar high!
blue011008
Nice ideas! When I was a kid I remembered I loved getting trinkets like this because I didn’t like candy very much and my parents wouldn’t let me eat much candy anyway.